Asked by: Heng Mazeau
fine art fine art photography

Why does four change his vote to not guilty?

Last Updated: 24th May, 2020

30
Why does Four change his vote to not guilty? He thinks there's a reasonable doubt because juror 8 states that it's logical to say that she was not wearing her glasses in bed and she didn't put them on just to glance out a window which convinces him to change his vote.

Click to see full answer.

Similarly, you may ask, why did Juror 4 change his vote?

He is willing to listen and try to understand the others' points of views and gives their arguments credit where it is due, especially after analyzing the evidence, which had seemed to overwhelmingly prove the boy's guilt at first-Juror #4 changed his vote based on the realization that there indeed was reasonable doubt

Secondly, what reasons does Juror #8 give for originally voting not guilty? In the first vote, Juror 8 is the only one to vote not guilty. He does this not because he really feels that the defendant is necessarily innocent, but for another reason altogether. He votes not guilty because he feels that the group should discuss a case with such serious consequences before deciding.

Subsequently, question is, what did juror four do that keeps the group from being a hung jury?

He doesn't want to get off track so he sticks to his opinion. He tells them not to act like children and wants to keep talking about the case.

What comments does Juror Eight make that seem to settle the argument about doubt?

He repeats the evidence about the case, and it suggests that there is doubt; at least two agree, so they take another vote. To juror four, what is the most convincing evidence that the boy is guilty?

Related Question Answers

Azahra Geerdes

Professional

Why did Juror 9 change his vote?

Juror 9 is the first of the remaining eleven jurors to change his vote after the initial one. He does this, not because he has changed his mind, but to give support to Juror 8. At the beginning of Act II, Juror 9 says, ''He gambled for support, and I gave it to him.

Acher Larrayad

Professional

Why did Juror 11 change his vote?

Near the end of the play, Juror 7 announces that he's changing his vote to guilty, not because he believes the defendant might not be guilty, but because he has had enough and wants to go home. As earlier, Juror 7 tries to shut down Juror 11.

Natalja Husige

Professional

Why do the other jurors turn their back on Juror 10?

Why do the other jurors turn their backs on 10's statements about his true feelings? Because he was continuously ranting about how terrible certain groups are and saying terrible assuming things about people in the slums, and everyone was getting sick of his bigotry--it's offensive and was uncalled for.

Baerbel Grohsfeld

Explainer

Who is Juror 10 referring to when he says them?

Juror 10 indicates that all people like the boy on trial are liars based on experiences he seems to have had with them. In Act I he says, 'You're not going to tell us that we're supposed to believe him, knowing what he is. I've lived among 'em all my life. You can't believe a word they say.

Georgie Udot

Explainer

How old is the kid in 12 Angry Men?

In a New York City courthouse, an eighteen-year-old boy from a slum is on trial for allegedly stabbing his father to death. Final closing arguments having been presented, a visibly bored judge instructs the jury to decide whether the boy is guilty of murder.

Eman Seng

Explainer

What is the dramatic climax of 12 Angry Men?

Climax. The climax of Twelve Angry Men is when No. 8 explains to the rest that the woman across the street couldn't have seen the crime just casually looking out her window from her bed without her glasses as common sense would dictate that nobody wears their glasses to bed.

Alison Ameçua

Pundit

Who created 12 Angry Men?

12 Angry Men (1957 film)
12 Angry Men
Directed by Sidney Lumet
Produced by Henry Fonda Reginald Rose
Screenplay by Reginald Rose
Story by Reginald Rose

Ezahra Arcalles

Pundit

Why does #11 Question #7 so closely about his willingness to change his vote?

why does juror 11 question juror 7 so closely about his willingness to change his vote? Juror 3 voted guilty because he wanted to get it over with. He also didn't have enough courage to stand alone, nor was able to give facts to back up his reasoning for saying the boy was guilty.

Yunlong Vinhas

Pundit

What does Juror 3 do to Juror 8 in the beginning of Act 3?

What does Juror #3 do to Juror #8 in the beginning of Act III that causes the others to cry "Look out!" How is this also an example of situational irony? Juror #3 charges at Juror #8 as if he were to stab him. He was "demonstrating" the correct way to stab with the switchblade.

Tullio Ahrent

Pundit

What causes the conflict between jurors three and five at the opening of this scene?

What causes the conflict between jurors three and five at the opening of this scene? Juror three thinks the defendant is guilty, and juror five changes their verdict. Why does nine change his vote? Juror nine changes his vote because he doesn't want juror five standing alone.

Magina Arcaya

Pundit

What are the judge's instructions to the jury in 12 Angry Men?

What are the judges instructions to the jury? He tells them they must decide the guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. All twelve must vote guilty or not guilty; otherwise there will be no verdict, and it will be a hung jury.

Mounaim Lastirigoyen

Teacher

Which three jurors are the most stubborn?

Answer: Jurors 10, 3, and 12 in my opinion the most stubborn because 10 is a bigot, 3 is very opinionated and 12 is a hurried business man who sees everything in black and white.

Souhila Hicham

Teacher

Seckou Zacharie

Teacher

Why is Juror 8 a hero?

Juror 8 is a hero because of his revolt against the status quo. The 8th juror is the first to vote not guilty because of his reasonable doubt and he had the confidence to stand up for his beliefs. He is the first juror to vote completely opposite from everyone else.

Benigna Quecchia

Teacher

Who changed their vote in Twelve Angry Men?

It is Juror Nine, the elderly man on the jury, who changes his vote from guilty to not guilty at the end of Act One, and he is the first juror to do so. Juror Nine changes his vote to support Juror Eight, who wants to discuss the evidence before reaching a verdict.

Nedyalka Zeala

Reviewer

Which jurors change their vote?

Jurors 12 and 4 change their vote to "not guilty".

Sixta Chazov

Reviewer

What does a deadlocked jury mean?

Deadlocked Jury is a jury that, despite honest attempts, is unable to reach a verdict by the required voting margin. Often, a deadlocked jury will lead to a retrial of the case. A jury unable to come to a final decision, resulting in a mistrial.

Dario Elliott

Reviewer

What does eight say bothered him about the boy's trial?

What does EIGHT say bothered him about the boy's trial? He doesn't think the defendant's attorney did a good job or defending the kid.

Nisamar Muldashev

Reviewer

What was juror 10 motive in voting guilty?

Juror 10. Juror 10 is the secondary antagonist in the 1957 film, Twelve Angry Men. His motive for voting the defendant guilty is because he had a prejudice against the people from the boy's neighborhood, which are called 'Slums'.